
Doomsday at the Legacy Pit Open II: An Interview with RoseIsland
Immolation is the sincerest form of flattery.
Preface
Salutations!
As the nights get darker, the wiki seems to get more active. Almost like it's not as nice to go outside these days... Oh well! That means more Doomsday content for everyone!
Just like last year the Legacy Pit hosted their open with a very strong turnout from players all over the US and Canada. This was hosted the 1st and 2nd of October and had 306 players pit themselves (pun intended) against each other. Of course, like last year, there are already reports, reviews and all manner of quality content flying in from the event so to make sure Doomsday is not missing out, I have tried to gather so bits from pilots who were representing us there!
I've managed to get 3 written reports and 1 online interview for your viewing/listening pleasure and am delighted to present them here alongside with an overall review of the different decklists for Doomsday and their respective performances.
For the wider meta and to follow the decklists within the event it can all be found online along with the organiser's website (they produce a lot of good content so please check them out!):
- Event MtGMelee Page
- The Legacy Pit Website
- Data analysis courtesy of the Legacy Data collection project
The Interview with Samantha RoseIsland Murphy
Linked below you can find a link to the interview I (Doishy) had with RoseIsland. They had the highest placing result of all the Doomsday pilots represented managing to make it into the top 8 and did so with a novel take on the more Tempo based approaches that some have been working on, but to a much smaller scale than that put into more Turbo variants. The interview goes over the preperation, decklist choices and gameplay across the event as well as touching on some other topics that are worthwhile having a listen to! Alas it is only available on Youtube because other platforms require $$$ to host on them.
Main 60
4
Brainstorm
4
Ponder
4
Dark Ritual
2
Fatal Push
4
Daze
1
Pyroblast
1
Young Pyromancer
1
Thassa's Oracle
4
Baleful Strix
3
Expressive Iteration
4
Doomsday
4
Force of Will
4
Murktide Regent
1
Flooded Strand
1
Badlands
1
Island
1
Cavern of Souls
1
Mystic Sanctuary
4
Polluted Delta
4
Scalding Tarn
4
Underground Sea
3
Volcanic Island
Sideboard 15
2
Opposition Agent
2
Unlicensed Hearse
2
Pyroblast
2
Hydroblast
2
Fatal Push
1
Meltdown
1
Rough // Tumble
1
Red Elemental Blast
1
Brazen Borrower // Petty Theft
1
Hidetsugu Consumes All // Vessel of the All-Consuming
Samantha has also written up a 2 part primer if you are interested in finding out more about their style of Tempo Doomsday. This can be found on the MinMax blog:
Reports
Romario once again returns this year to provide us a cheeky little report on how his event went.
Romario's Report - 17th Place on UB Turbo Doomsday
Romario's Twitter Romario's Twitch
Hello, Romario here again with another tournament report, another Pit Open, more doomsday content from me, I am pretty bad at making notes at tournaments so the following will be situations I found interesting or moments at the event that could be relevant for other Doomsday players.
Little bit about the event, the guys from the Pit Open organized one of the larger legacy events last year towards the end of the pandemic when the restrictions were beginning to be lifted off and they organized the second Legacy Pit Open on the weekend of October 1st 2022, the event took place in my hometown Richmond, VA (super convenient for me lol) at the Greater Richmond Convention Center, same venue SCG hosted their Opens/Invitationals and WotC hosted GPs and a couple of PTs in the past.
Main 60
1
Lion's Eye Diamond
3
Lotus Petal
4
Brainstorm
1
Consider
4
Personal Tutor
4
Ponder
4
Dark Ritual
3
Duress
1
Thoughtseize
1
Daze
2
Thassa's Oracle
2
Cabal Ritual
2
Edge of Autumn
4
Doomsday
1
Deep Analysis
4
Force of Will
3
Street Wraith
1
Cavern of Souls
2
Flooded Strand
1
Island
1
Marsh Flats
1
Misty Rainforest
4
Polluted Delta
1
Scalding Tarn
1
Swamp
4
Underground Sea
Sideboard 15
1
Duress
1
Chain of Vapor
1
Hurkyl's Recall
1
Brazen Borrower
4
Force of Negation
2
Opposition Agent
2
Sheoldred, the Apocalypse
1
Mystic Sanctuary
1
Relic of Progenitus
1
Leyline of the Void
So here is how the event went for me:
Round 1 - Logan Powell - N/A
The event was running using the mtgmelee website, about 40min after the advertised starting time, I got the message for round 1 pairings and to my surprise my opponent didn't show up, 10 min. Later and I won the round.
2-0
1-0
Round 2 - Daniel Signorini - Jeskai Delver
Daniel is part of the original Northern Virginia legacy crew who used to play at the legendary Curio Cavern. I expected Delver and Daniel didn't disappoint except he was playing Jeskai Delver, G1 I never found a Doomsday and lost. G2 I was able to resolve Doomsday and make a PTT pile with perfect information after a couple of Duress, Daniel did cast a Surgical Extraction for extra information and knew I was on the Sheoldred, the Apocalypse plan . G3 I resolved a Sheoldred early, my opponent cast 2 Brainstorms and the life loss was too much after they got Brainstorm locked.
2-1
2-0
Round 3 - Benjamin Chen - Yorion DnT
We sat down and my opponent had a Eternal Weekend Europe eldrazi playmat, I surely expected to have to fight through some Chalice of the Void and Thought-Knot Seer instead they showed me a Yorion pre-game and cast an Aether Vial on turn 1, not a whole lot to report here I resolved Doomsday early on games 1 and 2 and made some bullet proof PTT piles.
2-0
3-0
Round 4 - Matt Bessel - Mono White Painter
Me and my opponent made some small talk, rolled two dice to see who would play first, my opponent then cast a turn 1 Esper Sentinel off a plains, I thought for sure it was some DnT variant I was also not happy at all to play against a turn 1 sentinel, then things got worse when he cast an Ethersworn Canonist on t2 and a second canonist on t3, at this point I knew the game was over but continued to played to see what they were playing. Turns out on turn 4 they played an Urza's Saga and a Painter's Servant, which meant besides the hate bears I would also need to fight through Grindstone. G2 and 3 I mulled to hands that could cast Doomsday early and cast DD on t1 and t2 respectively never giving them a chance to play lock pieces.
2-1
4-0
Round 5 - Quang Vu - 8-Cast
This round I believe I was sitting at table 2, Michael Yue who was also playing vs an 8-Cast opponent was at table 3 and Max Carini at table 4. Spoiler alert we all won this round!
G1 Opponent cast a turn 1 Chalice but Cabal Ritual bailed me for a turn 2 DD and a unbeatable PTT pile. G2 I made my land drops and cast Doomsday the good honest way tapping 3 Underground Seas, opponent didn't have neither countermagic nor pressure on the board so just another PTT pile.
2-0
5-0
Round 6 - Patrick Humfleet - Naya Depths
This match was featured and can be found in the event archive from the Legacy Pit twitch channel. Twitch VOD
2-0
6-0
Round 7 - Max Carini - Doomsday
Doomsday was going well in the event and we had we knew the mirror match was going to happen eventually, me and Max sat down do play knowing pretty much each other's 75, g1 Max cast a Personal Tutor tried to resolve a DD which I countered, he followed up by playing the same sequence again PT-> DD and this time I didn't have the countermagic but I had my own DD + cycler, all I needed was to draw a mana source, I drew a cabal rit and comb'd the same turn, I knew Max would win if I passed the turn and he also had no cards in hand. G2 I suspected I was going to see an opposition agent and on turn 3 or 4 I cast a duress, Max responded with an Opposition Agent I fetched in response, let agent resolve, discarded then followed up with ritual into Sheoldred, and got a concession a couple of turns later.
2-0
7-0
Round 8 - Ryan Mullens - UR Delver
So I knew my last round of the day would be either delver or 8-Cast, it was delver, very interesting match, interesting situation in g1, I drew DD at exactly 4 life facing a 3/3 Dragon's Rage Channeller, unfortunately my hand was Doomsday + Street Wraith, I say unfortunately because at 2 more life I could safely make a Consider pile or if the cycler was edge, my opponent's hand only had a Ledger Shredder, but they also had a Wasteland in play, I ended up m aking a pile that lost to that on board Wasteland when a basic Brainstorm pile would had won. G2 an early Duress allowed me to resolve a DD with perfect information on t3 and make a win on the same turn pile, g3 it was a delver game, it flipped and when I cast a duress I saw a hand with 2 Force of Will, 2x Murktide Regent, Daze and a Pyroblast, and that was the end of day 1.
1-2
7-1
Round 9 - Bob Huang - 8-Cast
I knew Bob was on 8-Cast and planned accordingly, g1 I cast a t1 DD backed up by a Daze on my opponent's FoW, just made a PTT with some cyclers and a Cavern of Souls. G2 and 3 were pretty similar I cast Sheoldred early but Bob found Karakas and I couldn't resolve a Doomsday. G3 on the play I had the option to cast a DD on t1 with a SW in hand instead I went for Sheoldred, speaking with Michael BlackSkyDoc Yue between rounds I think going for DD was a much better option Sheoldred required more resources and wouldn't win the next turn, my reasoning at the time was that Sheoldred would dodge Force of Negation.
1-2
7-2
Round 10 - Harry Hacket - Maverick GWr
Another match a saw a green fetch on t1, I don't remember much from g1 but I believe it was a quick Doomsday, they did have 2 Endurances but I made a pile with 2 Thassa's Oracles, g2 I had to make a slow pile since they GSZ for a Collector Ouphe early in the game, I also kept cavern in the deck which proved to be a good choice after I saw pyroblast in that game.
2-0
8-2
Round 11 - Kris Rhinehart - Elves
These last 3 rounds were interesting to say the least, they were all elves, but not Elves!, they were Newton's creation elves, with Fiend Artisan and less elves than the traditional lists. G1 I cast a cantrip my opponent casts a free Once Upon a Time, they grab an Endurance, the following turn I cast Thoughtseize, discard Endurance, followed by Dark Ritual + DD, their hand was all lands, but it had a Boseiju so I made sure to put a land in my PTT pile, Kris discard Boseiju to destroy my Underground Sea and I searched up the other one in my deck, they said well played and we went to g2. This time the game went a bit longer, but Kris played a Fiend Artisan and I knew he was going to tutor up an Opposition Agent the next, I cast a DD and went for a Brainstorm pile that wins the same turn but would be soft to Endurance, they didn't have one and I won.
2-0
9-2
Round 12 - Matthew Szabo - Elves
This match was in the featured area but it didn't make it on stream, g1 I made what I thought was a pretty clever play, I cast PT for Doomsday, Matt cast a Fiend Artisan, next they got an Opposition Agent in play using Artisan, which normally makes things very difficult for Doomsday since the rogue creature doesn't let you search your deck and Doomsday is a search effect, but in this case I had TO in hand, I called a judge to make sure I understood it correctly, and in fact Doomsday removes deck and graveyard in this boardstate, I cast dark ritual + DD and played TO with an empty library. G2 I lost to an Endurance and having my life total pressured, g3 I kept a hand without lands but with 2x petals, Cabal Ritual and a Doomsday, it would be very hard to make a pile to play around Endurance and Boseiju, without knowing my opponent's hand I made a pile to beat Endurance, they had both Endurance and Boseiju.
1-2
9-3
Round 13 - Jakob Heckert - Elves
This match was also in the featured area but not the whole match since we were the back up match, kinda similar to the previous round, I won g1 without much problems with an early Doomsday, g2 lost to Endurance + Natural Order, g3 it was Endurance + Allosaurus Shepherd with another Elf attacking for 10.
1-2
9-4
Final Thoughts
Finished in 17th place, and had a lot of fun playing what is my favorite combo deck to play, as for sideboard, I basically followed the guide Max Gilmore posted, changed a few things when facing MUs that weren't on the guide, but as a rule of thumb, I cut discard and PTs vs decks that play to the board like DnT, 8-Cast and Maverick for cars like Chain of Vapor and Opposition Agent; for decks that could cast problematic permanents I brought Force of Negations. The only card I would cut for a next event is Mystic Sanctuary, I know the idea was to have a card for slower games which your opponent doesn't attack your lands, I didn't play against any of those decks at the Pit Open but in testing on mtgo the card was not very good, other than that I was very happy with the list.
It was a great weekend, well run event, it was great to see all the other Doomsday people from the discord and seeing Samantha crush the competition on her way to top 8, Max finishing in 12th and Michael in 18th.
BlackSkyDoc's Report - 18th Place on UB Turbo Doomsday
We also have a report from regular grinder on the MTG Paper Legacy circuit BlackSkyDoc!
Main 60
2
Street Wraith
2
Thassa's Oracle
2
Personal Tutor
4
Doomsday
3
Duress
2
Edge of Autumn
1
Ideas Unbound
1
Cabal Ritual
4
Ponder
1
Consider
1
Thoughtseize
1
Pact of Negation
4
Brainstorm
4
Dark Ritual
4
Daze
4
Force of Will
1
Lion's Eye Diamond
3
Lotus Petal
1
Verdant Catacombs
1
Misty Rainforest
4
Polluted Delta
2
Flooded Strand
1
Scalding Tarn
1
Snow-Covered Island
1
Snow-Covered Swamp
1
Cavern of Souls
4
Underground Sea
Sideboard 15
2
Mystical Dispute
2
Flusterstorm
2
Opposition Agent
4
Force of Negation
1
Duress
1
Chain of Vapor
2
Defense Grid
1
Surgical Extraction
Round 1 - Ryan Hayes - 4C Control
G1 on the draw, opp mulls to 6. Opponent leads Island-Forest- while I cantrip and cast DD on T2 off of DR with a blue fetch still in play. FOW pitching Narset, Parter of Veils meets FOW pitching Ponder. Make the following pile with a SW in hand.





T3 opponent plays a Tropical Island and passes. T3 draw Edge, pass. T4 oppponent plays Prismatic Vista, passes. T4 draw TO. Cycle SW, play Cavern and TO. Opponent evokes an Endurance pitching Sylvan Library. T5 opponent draws and says go. T5 draw TO. Play TO. Opponent plays Endurance targeting me with DD and SW in the yard. The Endurance trigger resolves, and they play Swords to Plowshares on an oracle. I fetch and the TO trigger resolves with DD and SW in deck.
SB: - Swamp, - SW, - Consider. +2 Mystical Dispute, + Duress
G2 on the draw. I mulligan to 5 after seeing hands with 5 lands and no lands. I cast a T3 DD which meets a FOW that I can't counter. They cast Surgical Extraction on the Doomsday. I don't have the heart to go for a Street Wraith beats win and concede. I noted they played a Volcanic Island and Tundra during the game.
G3 on the play. Keep a banger of a hand. T1 I cast Ponder. T2 I cast Duress seeing [Island, FOW, FOW, Torpor Orb, Sylvan Library, and Endurance], taking Torpor Orb. Continue to cast DR and DD with FOW backup for their FOW. Make the following pile:





They play Island and pass. T3 I cast Ideas Unbound, cycle SW, play Cavern and TO, and pact the Endurance.
2-1
1-0
Round 2 - Caleb Devany - Naya Depths
G1 — on the play I mull to 5 and the opponent mulls to 6. An early Duress sees Knight of the Reliquary, Dryad Arbor, Flagstones of Trokair, Ramunap Excavator, and some lands (oof). I end up casting Doomsday on turn three off of three Underground Sea and promptly am hit with three Wastelands. Knight of the Reliquary beats finish me off before I can draw enough of the pile.
G2 & 3 — fairly easy wins. Piles were










2-1
2-0
Round 3 - Jon Wood - BR Goblins
G1 — on the draw. Opponent mulligans to 6, and I mulligan to 5. He leads with a Cavern of Souls that casts a Skirk Prospector. He misses land drops while I cast Doomsday and win.
+1 Chain of Vapor +2 Opposition Agent -2 Daze -1 Duress
G2 — on the draw. We both keep a full grip. He leads on Goblin Lackey, which attacks on T2. I flash in an Opposition Agent off Dark Ritual and the game ends a few turns later after casting Doomsday. Pile was:





2-0
3-0
Round 4 - Aleksander Tash - UR Delver
This matchup goes according to plan — cast a discard spell and Doomsday over the first two turns while having mana up for Daze. The pile in both games was:





2-0
4-0
Round 5 - Joey Funderburk - 8-Cast
Didn't take many notes for this match vs. 8-Cast
Piles were





and





Romario and Wonderpreaux were playing next to me and our Doomsday cabal went 6-0 this round!
2-0
5-0
Round 6 - Samantha Murphy - Tempo Doomsday
Game 1 — on the draw. Mulligan to 6. An early discard spell sees Murktide, Daze, Expressive Iteration, Brainstorm, and Polluted Delta. I take the Brainstorm and die to an 8/8 Murktide Regent five turns later.
Game 2 — on the play I mulligan to 6 and have three discard spells, Doomsday, and two lands! I cast Duress on the first turn, seeing Badlands, Ponder, Expressive Iteration, Doomsday, Murktide Regent, Pyroblast and Force of Will. I take Force of Will. They play Badlands. I cast another discard spell and see another Force of Will, which I discard. They draw and pass the turn. I cast Doomsday and get forced, then die to Murktide Regent four turns later.
0-2
5-1
Round 7 - Harlan Firer - 4C Stoneblade
Harlan and I had played against each other during the team SCG event in Baltimore the month prior and we both suspected the opponent was on the same deck. I remembered that he did not have Endurance in the deck, which let me go for more aggressive piles.
Game 1 — on the play. A T1 discard spell sees Force of Will, Force of Will, Ice-Fang Coatl, Brainstorm, Snapcaster Mage, Flooded Strand, Flooded Strand. I choose Force of Will. On T2 I go for DD with Force backup and they're unable to Brainstorm into a third force. Since they have no clock, I go for a double pass-the-turn pile to win.





SB: - Swamp, -3 Daze, - Thassa's Oracle. +2 Flusterstorm, +2 Mystical Dispute, +1 Duress.
Game 2 — on the draw T2 cast DD with Force backup. It resolves.





2-0
6-1
Round 8 - Jacob Heckert - Elves
Game 1 - Mull to 6 on the play. Opponent leads with a Green Sun's Zenith for Dryad Arbor, then plays Allosaurus Shepherd, Gaea's Cradle, and Collector Ouphe, which keeps me from winning on my third turn. I die on his T3 to a Craterhoof Behemonth. Ouphe.
SB: -3 duress, +2 Opposition Agent, +1 Chain of Vapor
Game 2 — Mulligan to 6 on the play. T1 Thoughtseize takes an Endurance and I resolve Doomsday on turn two. With Thassa's Oracle already in hand, I make a quad-cycle pile with chain of vapor as insurance and win the next turn.
Game 3 — Mulligan to 5 on the draw. I keep Doomsday, Lotus Petal, Brainstorm, fetchland, Brainstorm. He leads with an allosaurus shepherd and follow up with Collector Ouphe. I end up in a position where I can't do a PTT pile without dying to a pile of 5/5s and can't win in the same turn due to Collector Ouphe.
1-2
6-2
Round 9 - Jeffrey Carr - UR Delver
This matchup goes according to plan — cast a discard spell and Doomsday over the first two turns while having mana up for Daze.
Game 1 — on the play with a full grip!





Game 2 — lose after making a pile that relies on a blue cantrip. They topdeck a REB effect and clock me before I draw again. Should have gone with a Street Wraith over Ponder.





Game 3 — I mull to 5 on the play, keeping three lands, Edge of Autumn, and Force of Will. Opponent keeps 7. They play Counterbalance on T2 and Maddening Hex on T3. I cast Doomsday on Turn 4 with a fetchland in play that resolves!





They pass twice and I am able to draw both cyclers and go for the perfect kill.
2-1
7-2
Round 10 - Hunter Nance - UR Delver
The opponent states that he didn't hear me call “odd” during the dice roll resulting in a re-roll that he won. Weird. End up losing 1-2. Cast Doomsday twice. In Games 1 and 2 made the following default pile





In game 3 I resolved Doomsday when my opponent had a revealed Surgical Extraction in hand and made the following pile with an Island and Swamp in play, and an Underground Sea in hand.





Needless to say, when they cast Surgical Extraction on Doomsday and find, I was sad and learned that one does not have to take the cards with Surgical. Since they had Bolt, Bolt, and a shuffle effect, a winning PTT pile would need to empty the deck without cycling Street Wraith. There aren't any piles with a >25% chance of winning the next turn, as all of them require drawing multiple cards, then using LED for mana while cycling into a draw spell.
1-2
7-3
Round 11 - Harry Hackett - Maverick
Matches were not remarkable.
2-0
8-3
Round 12 - RoodH - Worldgorger Dragon Combo
Having 8 forces makes this matchup very favored.
2-0
9-3
Round 13 - Aaron Belsky (Kizma!) - UR Delver
-This match is super tight - I take game 1 off of winning the roll and having Doomsday plus force on turn two. Game two they have double Bolt to kill me. In the last game, I have two Underground Sea (one tapped) and a Lotus Petal on the battlefield on T2. They have a Delver and tapped Volcanic Island. In hand I have a Duress, fetchland, Doomsday, Brainstorm, and an Edge of Autumn. I cast Duress, which gets dazed, and I pay with the Lotus Petal. He reveals a hand of Brazen Borrower, DRC, Murktide, and two lands! I can't take a card and pass the turn. He peels a blind Brainstorm that flips the Delver (lucky!). On my turn, I go for the kill - cast Doomsday, with the intention to make the following pile to win





Of course, he casts the Brainstorm here and after putting back two, he casts Force of Will pitching Brazen Borrower. I am unable to find another Doomsday in time and lose the match. Congrats to Kizma on his strong finish!
1-2
9-4
Final Thoughts
Here are my takeaways from the event:
-
2nd Thassa's Oracle — I made one pile with two Thassa's Oracle all day. I never saw a Stifle or Dress down, and the preferred plan for beating Endurance was Pact of Negation (though it is worse than double oracle against exactly two cast endurances). I pitched an Oracle to a Force once, but another blue card would have worked fine in that situation. I will be putting one Thassa's Oracle in my deck for the foreseeable future.
-
Ideas Unbound — I put it in a pile three times and was glad to have it. Pairs very well with Pact of Negation to beat Endurance. Would not cut. It certainly is weaker against decks with REB effects, but enables very safe piles if it resolves. Even if it gets countered, you still can cast a Thassa's Oracle with some amount of Pact of Negation / Cavern of Souls if the opponent doesn't have a fast enough clock.
-
Common piles — Due to the prevalence of REB effects, the most common play pattern was to resolve Doomsday and let the next spell on the stack be an uncounterable Thassa's Oracle. Thus, cyclers with Thassa's Oracle, Cavern of Souls, and Pact of Negation were the most common pile cards. Casting IU or cantrips to dig into a PTT pile after casting Doomsday was a recipe for losing to REB. Often times I would discard a opponent's hard counter/Endurance and then cast Dark Ritual-Doomsday into a hand with a REB, so post-pile blue spells that can be countered were dubious.
-
Pact of Negation — Don't cast it to resolve Doomsday unless you have a same-turn kill and are confident that risking it are the best line! I can't see cutting the first Pact of Negation, as it is my preferred anti-endurance card at present. Is weak to REB if the opponent also has endurance.
BWand's Report - 276th Place with Esper Doomsday
I just want to make a special comment to say thankyou to BWand for submitting this despite the less than optimal result. Winning isn't everything and sometimes the most useful or interesting information can come from losses just as much! I have a lot of respect for BWand for both providing this and playing out a full 6 rounds. - Doishy
Main 60
4
Brainstorm
4
Ponder
2
Preordain
1
Thoughtseize
2
Spell Pierce
1
Batterskull
1
Kaldra Compleat
1
Lotus Petal
1
Predict
1
Unearth
1
Street Wraith
1
Thassa's Oracle
4
Dark Ritual
4
Doomsday
4
Baleful Strix
4
Stoneforge Mystic
4
Force of Will
2
Teferi, Time Raveler
4
Flooded Strand
1
Cavern of Souls
1
Marsh Flats
4
Polluted Delta
1
Swamp
1
Island
3
Underground Sea
1
Tundra
1
Scrubland
1
Watery Grave
Sideboard 15
3
Prismatic Ending
1
Plains
2
Sheoldred, the Apocalypse
4
Swords to Plowshares
1
Surgical Extraction
3
Force of Negation
1
Lion's Eye Diamond
Pre-Event Preperation
Legacy pit II prep: preparing started the event 6 months prior to the event. Not knowing for sure what to play, researching various tournaments and decks. I knew delver and GW depths were a large part of the meta, and putting up results in recent events. Due to the influence of, the infamous Doomsday player, Emidln — Brandon a good friend and knowledgeable source. I am familiar and a novice when playing traditional Doomsday, but Esper Doomsday inched its way into my sights. The play style is similar to my liking, combo player at heart, taking Omnishow 12-3 back at GP Louisville. And obtained mythic rank in mtg arena the month prior to build mental fortitude preparing for the long days of magic. Didn't help I was traveling 2am-3pm, by car to STL, plane to CHI met up with Emidln, to board the plane to Richmond.
Choice of deck/construction theory: Esper Doomsday w/ SFM package. The straight forward line of Doomsday into Predict name Thassa's Oracle, mill over Oracle, draw into Lotus Petal/Unearth. Unearth Oracle to win. With alternate creature/equipment of BS/SFM/BSkull/KC. SB consisting of the best white removal in the format STP and Prismatic Ending, more countermagic in FoN, interaction, a Plains, and Sheoldred. I wanted to play with Sheoldred, with the potential of just changing the game in your favor if you resolve, and protect Sheoldred. Every cantrip the opponent has shocks them . While every draw and cantrip you play extends the game. Also Sheoldred survives most removal in legacy because of the relevant 5 toughness. In consideration and deck building, there were times where instead of the SFM package, 4x MurkTide 2x Sheoldred was considered for the mainboard.
Emidln wanted me to play UR Delver due to it being tier 0. And that I had experience with the deck. We played roughly 20 games the night before the tournament to determine what deck to play. Either UR or EsperDDay. Ultimately, I chose to play Doomsday.
Event report: 1-5 drop. I wanted to play as much of the deck as possible.
Round 1 - Michael Fei on UR Delver
The opponent played tight and hit every answer to my combo. They had Bolt, Bolt, Delver for the win.
1-2
0-1
Round 2 - Travis Weeks - UR Delver
The opponent main boarding Counterbalance.
Blind flipping triggers that sealed them the game.
0-2
0-2
Round 3 - Michael Wood - Helm Combo
Opponent beat me down with the Dauthi Voidwalker 3/2. I lost game to due to having no second Oracle in the deck.
0-2
0-3
Round 4 - Anderson Hunt - Bant Loam
They had just started Legacy a couple months ago. They were playing very well but could not overcome the countermagic while protecting a Batterskull-equipped Baleful Strix.
2-0
1-3
Round 5 - Paul Messplay - UWr Control
My opponent was a better control deck.
0-2
1-4
Round 6 - William Butler - Maverick
My creature package was short on damage. Took one game with Oracle.
1-2
1-5
Final Thoughts
Post event thoughts: the event was a good experience,some of my plays were sloppy needing more playtesting, get more sleep before. As for the deck, I was wanting Sheoldred and Murktide in the main instead of SFM after the event. I felt Sheoldred was a powerful card that the opponent had to answer. Murktide would have been better than the non flyer SFM package. Not to mention works better with a late game Doomsday.
Tournament was great experience and will be a stop for me in the future.
Doomsday's Overall Performance
Thank-you again to all those who contributed above!
We'll now go into a quick summary of the decks that were run and the overall meta and performance of Doomsday at the event.
Data Discussion
Once again thanks to the lovely efforts of the Legacy Collection Project and the providing of decklists by The Legacy Pit on mtgmelee, we can look at the metagame and performance ratings as a whole. To the surprise of no one (except maybe WotC it seems) UR Delver was the highest represented archetype at 17% and boasted a powerful 55.17% non mirror match win rate. The fact that 4 UR Delver decks converted to top 8 shows just how dominant this archetype looks.
Traditionally UR Delver has been the defacto kryptonite for Doomsday lists however it doesn't look like that put a dampener on the performance of the 8 pilots that took our favourite spell along for the day. Looking at all archetypes with at least 2 players representing Doomsday boasts the highest win rate of any archetype at 65.82%! The only two decks that actually were ahead of it in the event were powerful performances by individual pilots on their respective decks. That's pretty good one might say!
Many people seem to forget about Doomsday due to the relatively low numbers that it puts forwards in terms of represenation but this seems to indicate it is one of the best things to be doing in the format right now. Looking at the other popular decks represented; GW Depths, 8-Cast, Death and Taxes, Elves, Reanimator and some Ux Control strategies, we can see many of them are very favourable matchups for Doomsday. I think it is very well placed and with the right configuration can easily spike through a large event with ease.
Lists Discussion
Across the 8 Doomsday lists the event had we saw 1 Grixis Tempo variant, 2 Esper variants with a more control based focus (1 of which included a maindeck Stoneforge Mystic package), 1 UB Turbo list with Grief and 4 UB Turbo variants without Grief. Of the decks, 3 were running the new Sheoldred as a sideboard plan, usually alongside other creatures.
Doomsday took a top 8 spot alongside 12th, 17th, 18th places giving an impressive 50% conversation to the top 32. It was mostly the UB Turbo variants that did well with the Esper lists not placing quite so highly. It might be that the loss to speed and the greater focus towards a longer or fairer gameplan was not as favoured in this metagame however the Grixis Tempo list getting to the top 8 could disuade this argument. Perhaps the Esper lists lacking both Expressive Iterarion as guranteed card advantage and Red Blast effects to combat a lot of what the meta is doing was the primary downfall.
What's really cool to see is that none of the lists played are the same. Every single one has a number of flex slots or sideboard configuration choices unique to it and it reinforces just how versatile the archetype is. Breaking down the numbers the only shared slots consistent across all 8 lists were 4 ofs for Doomsday, Ponder, Brainstorm, Dark Ritual and Force of Will, 1 ofs for Cavern of Souls and from there it's a real mixed bag. Most lists favoured 2 Oracles but some opted for only a singleton. Daze was under-represented which shows the trend in pilots dropping it often at the moment with only an average of 1.5 copies per list. Force of Negation was the highest represented Sideboard card with at least 3 copies per list.
Every Doomsday list in the event can be found below:
- Top 8 - Samantha RoseIsland Murphy - Grixis Tempo
- 12th Place - Max Wonderpreaux Carini - UB Turbo ft. Grief
- 17th Place - Romario Romariovidal Neto - UB Turbo ft. Sheoldred
- 18th Place - Michael BlackSkyDoc Yue - UB Turbo
- 38th Place - Brandon emidln Adams - UB ABCD
- 79th Place - Facuando ChuckConde Conde - Esper ft. Dakkon!
- 106th Place - Brandon Darnell - UB Turbo ft. Sheoldred
- 276th Place - Brett BWand Wands - Esper Tempo ft. SFM
Final Thoughts
Once again thank you to The Legacy Pit for hosting a wonderful event, thankyou to our contributors and to all the pilots who chose to represent Doomsday at the event. It's always cool getting people on to contribute and I look forward to seeing more contributions from others in the future! If you want to write up an event report and need somewhere to host it please reach out to us at any time!
Otherwise Good Luck and Have Fun at whatever events are happening near you! xx.
For more content, please check out our resources page which includes a list of community streamers. If you would like to submit content to the Wiki, feel free to reach to us in the Doomsday Discord.